A Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA) is a legal agreement entered into between a prosecutor and a corporation (or sometimes an individual) facing potential criminal charges. Instead of immediately pursuing a criminal indictment and trial, the prosecutor agrees to defer prosecution if the company fulfills certain conditions over a specified period. These conditions often involve significant financial penalties and mandated reforms within the company’s operations.
From a financial perspective, DPAs represent a substantial risk and cost for businesses. The financial penalties imposed are frequently substantial, running into millions or even billions of dollars. These penalties are designed to be punitive, serving as a deterrent to future misconduct and compensating for the harm caused by the alleged criminal activity. The size of the fine is typically determined by a number of factors, including the severity of the alleged crime, the extent of the damage caused, the company’s ability to pay, and the level of cooperation demonstrated by the company during the investigation.
Beyond the direct financial penalty, DPAs often require companies to undertake costly remedial measures. These can include implementing new compliance programs, enhancing existing compliance controls, hiring independent monitors to oversee the company’s operations, and dismissing or reassigning employees involved in the alleged wrongdoing. The cost of these measures can be significant, especially for large, complex organizations. The independent monitor, in particular, can wield considerable influence within the company and has the authority to scrutinize virtually all aspects of the business.
The financial implications of a DPA extend beyond the direct costs of fines and remediation. The announcement of a DPA can negatively impact a company’s stock price, reputation, and ability to attract and retain customers and employees. Investors may become wary of the company, fearing further investigations or liabilities. Customers may lose trust in the company’s products or services, leading to a decline in sales. Employees may become demoralized or seek employment elsewhere, disrupting the company’s operations.
Furthermore, failing to comply with the terms of a DPA can have dire consequences. If a company violates the agreement, the prosecutor can revive the original criminal charges and proceed to trial. This could result in even greater financial penalties, including criminal fines and asset forfeiture, as well as the reputational damage associated with a criminal conviction. In some cases, a criminal conviction could even lead to the debarment of the company from government contracts.
In summary, DPAs are a significant tool used by prosecutors to hold corporations accountable for alleged criminal conduct. The financial implications of a DPA can be substantial, encompassing direct penalties, costly remedial measures, and the potential for reputational damage and business disruption. Companies facing potential criminal charges must carefully consider the terms of a DPA and the long-term financial consequences of entering into such an agreement.